I never smelt the original from Penhaligon's, but I smelt other alternative from other fragrances oils companies. I like Perfume Parlour proposal. It smells smoky and a bit sweet for some hours, I like the smell a lot. It tends to turn on the sweet side after some hours, but the smell is still good.
Another beauty from PP, this is the 3rd I've acquired with similarities to Penhaligans range namely Rumkale (Halfeti), Flaring for Men (Blazing Mr Sam) & this one which I adore even though I've never smelled the originals. All have good longevity for edp's although do have Extrait version of Rumkale 'Beast Mode!'. PP have excelled again really liking these fragrances at affordable prices & of a higher quality than others I've used.
Noisy For Men 1913
Option Review:13ml Spray
Yes I can see the similarity with Tobacco Vanille but to my nose its a very different beast and its the rose coming through that transforms it. Beautiful.
Option Review:30ml Spray
Stunning!! A warm honeyed tobacco. Opens up with rum and spices and the rich honey joins in and this is amazing! Not tried the original but I have previously purchased PP version of TF Tobacco Vanille. They are very similar and my husband enjoys that one a lot. But for me I love the honey note in this and it's 100% unisex. Thank you Perfume Parlour for these wonderful creations at affordable prices and high quality oils. Xx